i think something like epoxy or jb weld will hold it. then you can probably use plaster or something to smooth it out. if you know someone who does airbrushing then they could paint the plaster repair job to match with ease.
those are my thoughts. good luck!
Thanks a lot! I think I know someone on another forum who does taxidermy and I'm going to see if he can give me any pointers as well since he might deal with this kind of stuff.
Hahah I actually already did that! As soon as the I pulled myself together by being attacked by those things I duct taped them together with a whole bunch of black duct tape but it just wasn't holding and it all started to fall off again