You can't hook over a 400 Watt heating element to a herpstat Pro! That is the most it will push!
Watts = Amps X Voltage
Voltage = Amps X Resistance
If you increase the resistance in the circuit voltage will go up to maintain a given amount of Amps through the circuit. If Voltage goes up to keep Amps the same then Watts go up! More Watts a proportional controller pushes out the hotter the internal circuitry will get. The hotter the internal circuitry gets the more likely failure becomes.