I did try again this morning, and when I got all the shed softened, I sort of pinched the edge at the back of her head between my fingers to see how loose it was. Tonks jerked her head really hard, but at just the right angle, and everything else came off including the second eyecap. I'd have preferred to be a bit more gentle, but she's the one who pulled! But she's fine now, other than being VERY offended at being manhandled, lol.

Then I check on my bigger girl, Ana Gwyn, and she's got a pink belly, SIGH. So I misted her tub really thoroughly and I'm going to make her another humidity box, she outgrew her old one. No more stuck shed!

Thanks for all the advice!