The thing is that the numbers shown on the thermostat were still giving me 89~92, while the temp gun gave me 83 at the same time (which is why I didn't find out until now... not sure how long this has been happening). While yesterday when I checked, the temp gun gave me 93 at one point when the numbers on the thermostat were showing something lower. So I guess I can assume it's more broken than it should be. :s
So the fluctuations are wide not because of the off-on in itself, but because something in the probe or temperature detecting function that turns it on/off is broken.
My other two Hydrofarms are offing and on-ing correctly, and though it has a wider fluctuation than a better quality thermostat, it generally stays within 88~92 on the hot spot and will show the correct temp accordingly on the thermostat.
I'm going to test this tonight... As a temporary fix, would plugging two UTH's into an extension cord, and plugging that into one Hydrofarm be too much to handle for the Hydrofarm? (I'm just assuming it's a weak thermostat...)