Yes, I believe I stated a lot of what he said makes sense...I also stated I have no experience with keeping animals this way and don't plan to try it now. I can tell you this method will NOT work with the lizards I keep, that being said it is hard to argue with his logic when you have zero first hand experience with said method. I simply said I still have my doubts based on my beliefs and the methods I have found to successfully keep animals...that being said, I bet it is safe to say at least half of this community doesn't think they way I keep my animals is necessary for their well being, which is why to each their own. What works for some will not work for others and visa versa.
I think he made a comment that it certainly wouldn't work for some lizards and tortoises but it was very brief.