I think you make an excellant point, ratings can have nothing to do with all aspects of making a decision on whether or not an example of a morph is good or bad.

My rating is a perfect example.....i give it a 3 because I like reduced pattern pins......does that make yours a bad example of the pin morph? Of course not.....I think that is a nice looking bp and with the right mate you can take advantage of that busy pattern appearance.....!