Quote Originally Posted by Colin Vestrand View Post
ha! well that's first i've heard that... sounds pretty far fetched. bull, pine, and gopher snakes are nothing like the rest of Elaphe/Pantherophis to me.
i know the original study was not approved, but a friend of mine had told me that the follow up is taken to be fact now; and since he's a herpetologist and a teacher at a major university i figure he knows what he's talking about.
I've PM'd you with original paper.....

Colin, I think the problem with the original study (other than the controversy with the DNA testing) is that it highlights an unresolved philosophical argument between cladists and more traditional taxonomists. It ultimately comes down to how you define paraphyletic - the cladists have been dismantling paraphyletic taxa and the traditionalists argue that Reptilia is monophyletic.

In other words - I think the split is due more in part to philosophical differences between two camps of taxonomists than any hard difference is genetics or morphology. Is Elaphe an unnatural polyphyletic assemblage of species? I don't think so, but apparently, people ultimately responsible for the official re-classification see the argument differently.

I have a feeling we're going to see a lot of these changes in the upcoming years.