Its not that he went in the water and got attacked... thats not the point I'm trying to make... Its the fact that he knew sharks feed in the morning... If you go into the woods and get attacked by a mountain lion bc your on a hike, no its not your fault... Just like it wouldnt have been his fault if it was 12 oclock and bright sunshine... But if mountain lions are known to attack say around dusk and you decide to take your walk then and get attacked... well yea id have to say your at fault bc youre smart enough... well supposed to be... to know that they feed mainly around dusk time and you can hold off on going hiking until another day.