Probing must be a fine art or something. I thought I was doing it right.. long story short, my "male" turned out to be a female (remember back when I tried breeding last year, and the one I thought was the male laid the eggs? lol.) This was a mistake by both me and the people who sold her to me; heck, I know they thought she was a male, as NO ONE in their right mind would've sold me a fully grown, breedable and completely healthy female for $30!!! I got Her a few years ago at the Cheektowaga herp show this way.
But long story short, both the sellers, and later me, both probed her as a male.