I think the Super Vanilla likely has OD with as heavy as the blushing is. Vanilla Cream already have strong blushing, so that one is a bit more of a toss up.
They are both really nice looking. Really depends if these are for pets, or breeding and if breeding what kind of projects you are interested in. If it were me, I'd probably go with Super Vanilla for breeding because it's an easier ID and consistent on OS, plus Vanilla is a little more rare than Fire.