Oh that's a relief! Snakes don't assess the size of prey very well as far as deciding beforehand what prey will "fit", but when you spoke of your snake showing fear, I assumed you meant live prey, as that certainly could make a snake fearful. Rats bite hard, once their eyes are open & the older they get. Sorry I misunderstood you.
As already noted, I'd agree that the snake's reaction might be due to improper thawing. It's essential to thaw in ways that don't allow spoilage, since your snake can smell that. BPs don't normally consume carrion.