Yes, it is quite a different thing than accidental disability, I agree.
I guess I just can't agree that the negatives objectively outweigh the positives. It can be difficult to place values on either of these, especially when we don't have a lot of good research. What sort of impact does it have on the hobby or interest in reptile education in general to have some of these purposely bred oddities floating around for example? That's a very difficult thing to measure with a lot of variables.
One thing to note, I don't think it's nearly as much of an issue as "breeds" where breeders are restricting the gene pool so tightly. We never have to worry about all ball pythons disappearing or even a scaleless line disappearing over this because we are mostly breeding for morphs and combos, not avoiding introducing new blood into our lines. Some of these horrible traits in breeds are fixed there because the organizations and breeders involved have decided that purity of their lines is more important than the health of the breed. If at some point we decide, it is in fact objectively bad to produce scaleless animals, a breeder could very easily obtain animals with that removed from their line in a single generation of outbreeding and be done with it. Theoretically, dog breeders *could* outbreed and correct these problems, but it's more difficult because there are many different genes involved and a huge cultural structure built around purebreds.








Reply With Quote