Thank you so much for the feedback and insight!
I feel comfortable with both, so I will try later tonight to first uncurl and if that doesn't work, I'll proceed to the pulling method. I have some smaller surgical tweezers and smaller pliers that should work well if I need to go this route. I'll keep you posted on how it goes and if for some reason I'm unsuccessful I will take her to the vet.
Also happy to hear you haven't experienced this in a while!