I agree 100%- he wouldn't be keeping a penny from me either, not after what he pulled on you. And just because someone argues up a storm, doesn't mean they're right or have a leg to stand on...that's just how some people are, they'll always blame others & it's never anything they did wrong. Because all they care about is their own profits, & they've learned that by putting up a fight, they'll win a few because some will just give up & don't pursue what they're owed.