Neat stuff you are doing there. The problem with those analogs from the pet store is not that they are never accurate. I am sure there are a couple in a batch that are. The problem is that the build quality sucks and I have zero confidence that even two would give you the exact same reading. Analog is still great in my book, but a good analog anything requires at least periodic calibration. I have serious doubts that for the price of those gauges that they are or even can be calibrated. That said, I personally take humidity readings with my finger and it works for me. Don't ask. It's voodoo. lol