Ive only had a stuck eye cap twice. One on my BP and one on my Hoggy. Both times I was ale to place my finger on top of their head and slide to the rim of the eye. With hardly any pressure I was able to get the cap to pop off. If you feel comfortable doing this you could try it. If not, I would just wait for the next shed. Make sure the humidity is good and maybe even give it a bit of a boost.