I would try with substrate and if it doesn't give you the results you want the only thing I could think of is a faulty rhp. Never heard of that problem from reptile basics but could happen. I have pretty much the same conditions as you but my cage is 4 inches longer and I'm having no problem, only difference is I'm testing with substrate and acurite thermometers with probes and also temp guns.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G890A using Tapatalk