Update -
I shot Big Cheese an email and expressed my liking for the quality of the feeders, but my dislike for the weights received. I'm not a complainer and would definitely not usually do something like this, but I wanted them to have the same feedback that I provided here, especially since I emailed them ahead of time of what to expect size-wise. I didn't attack them at all and just laid out the facts. Received a response a couple of hours later from Chris and was happy with what I read. Seems like a good guy. He told me to ask for him when I place another order that he'd fill the order himself to be sure I got some fat ones. I'm fine with that.