May be heated up to much. It only takes a large mouse 10 minutes to thaw out in hot water. The heat lamp might be cooking it. Try putting mouse in bag and put in 100 degree water for 5-10 minutes. Check on it and make sure there's no frozen spots left and then take a hair dryer or your heat lamp and only heat up the head of the mouse.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G890A using Tapatalk