I discarded the Hatchrite already, so I just added vermiculite that was probably slightly wetter than average, but they're on light diffuser and both tubs are tightly re-sealed. My boyfriend and I prepped everything and transferred everything pretty quickly and carefully. The eggs feel quite dehyrdated, with a couple showing the very slightest signs of mold(so slight that it might be my imagination, but still..) All still showing veins, though. I've been monitoring the temps and humidity over the past hour and humidity rose to 87% and is now sitting. If it doesn't continue to rise, I'll add more water tonight, but I'm hoping to not have to mess with these babies anymore.
I know the first season can be a bit of trial and error, but I reeeeally hope it doesn't cost my first clutch.