You do have a thermostat on the uth?
I have used moist moss for years without issue. I keep it moist during a shed but during non shed times I allow it to dry out before making it moist again.
Aspen is not a very good choice as it does not hold humidity well. I like cypress mulch. I actually use a mixture of cypress, eco earth, and repti bark in most of my cages.
Switching the substrate and adding some moss should help you a lot.
Placing a damp towel on top of the screen will cause the mesh to rust over time. A better option may be cutting a insert to place on it instead. I cut cardboard and then wrapped it with foil to place on my large glass tank. It works just fine.
Analog hygrometers are notorious for being inaccurate. It may be that or it may be their placement. The gauges will serve you best low where the snake is. They should be just an inch or so from the substrate.