Well they are on/off thermostats so it's only ever going to be on or off. I don't believe there's a way to set their buffer time between kicking on. An STC 1000 would allow you to change that but is still an on/off controller. (I use a pair of them for my UTH and heat lamp)
Where's the probe located relative to a hot spot? Do you have a second way to check the temps because that's a very huge difference in temperature? Maybe your IR thermometer is being finicky.