I have never had any problems with the holes in the Home Depot tubs. I concur with JohnNJ. You have to take the time to make sure that the tubs fit properly. This will alleviate more problems associated with chew outs.

When I install the rails that my tubs slide on I always turn the rack upside down and use the actual tub itself as a spacer. This lets me know that each tub will fit perfectly and that the hardware cloth will be right up against the plastic. Using this method I have never had a chewed tub.

Also, you have to cull chewers. Chewers and biters meet the same fate at my place. If they bite anything other than a block of food they end up as snake poop. End of story.