She is a fire. I can pretty much guarantee it. I breed them, and she is a very fine example. Looks a lot like my own adults. Your fire, on the left of the picture, is a pretty standard fire. Lots of blushing and flames, but overall a darker body color. The one in the water dish doesn't even look like a fire. It's very dark and has little in the way of blushing or flames, at least in that photo. That one actually makes me think vanilla. I have a really nice Gulf Coast line vanilla, and when seen side by side with a fire, the vanilla tends to be darker and more golden/yellow, whereas a fire will be lighter and more creamy.
Gale