"Good eggs" was meant to be as in healthy and a "decent" quantity. 3-4 eggs for a first or second year girl and I would still keep her. If she has given me 8-10 eggs in prior years and she is now down to 3-4 that would be a tough call. 3-4 eggs is better than none when I have the room and I'm looking for a certain morph in return.... ie- I have a 1.0 Sugar Fire, and I want a 0.1 Sugar Fire, 0.1 Sugar Pastel or 1.0/0.1 Sugar Firefly.