I would suggest trying live again, but as mentioned, get a deli cup. Just put the deli cup down in the substrate (I'd give it back, they like to dig.) and leave the pinky in there. Worse case scenario is you can put her in there with it and put a lid on it (with air holes obviously).

I've gotten hogs to eat just after getting them by offering a pinky while they are still in the deli cup.


Be careful though, now that you have an odd girl out. Soon you might find that you suddenly have more hogs than bp's.