I am smack dab in the middle, couldn't really pick one or other other. I currently have both, two of each, and there are times when they are both the greatest pets in the world, and other time they both annoy the hell out of me. Of course part of that may be because my cats have never been typical "cats" based on stereotypes, they've always been at least somewhat dog-like. My boy cat is VERY dog-like. He is my shadow too, follows me everywhere, and then tries to compete with the baby for lap space (even if that means laying ON TOP of the baby, good thing she's a year old and able to handle it! lol). He annoys the hell out of me, but at the same time he's great for a good cuddle when needed. The dogs are great too, but also annoying at times. I like them because I can take them with me, unlike the cats. Don't like them so much because they are more energetic and don't seem to be able to entertain themselves quite as easily at the cats. Both are great though.