Unfortunately, there is no place around here that I can get live pinkies, but I will definitely pick up some frozen mice and see if he likes those better. Maybe he just doesn't like the pink color of pinkies? The mice I've been feeding him are adults and they have brown fur. If I can at least get him to eat frozen mice, that will give me some hope. I also forgot about trying to feed him a f/t rodent right after he eats the live one, so I can still try that.

If I get really desperate, I can also go to the next reptile expo which is in 4 months and pick up some live pinkies, if they have any.

Thanks for the help, guys. If he's a mouser, I guess I'll just have to get used to it. I'm not gonna give up on him yet, though!