No, the feeding response will not be the same. Why would a snake react to a F/T rodent the same way they react to a live one? The smell is different, the temperature is different, the movement is different.

I've had some snakes that won't touch an ASF (live or otherwise), so don't rest all your hopes on ASFs being irresistible.

If a snake refuses F/T rats, you can always try a F/T ASF and see what happens.