Rodent Pro vs Mice Direct, what do you prefer?

[RideRed12]

Thinking about ordering some bulk F/T, with almost 10 snakes to feed its time to buy in bulk!

I would like to know whose tried either. What you liked, what you didn't like. Any bad experiences, and good? Pretty much all info is useful. If you have a different company to suggest, let me know!

Thanks everyone!

[Clementine_3]

I use The Mouse Factory and could not be happier.
I got a few orders from Rodent Pro (years ago, granted), the first few were fine but then they started coming with broken limbs and covered in urine/feces, really nasty. I called about the last order I placed, they apologized and sent another right out. It was equally gross and broken, there were a few headless rats in that order.
Switched to TMF and haven't looked back. They are always clean, whole and just incredibly well packed.

[Zombie]

I use The Mouse Factory and could not be happier.
I got a few orders from Rodent Pro (years ago, granted), the first few were fine but then they started coming with broken limbs and covered in urine/feces, really nasty. I called about the last order I placed, they apologized and sent another right out. It was equally gross and broken, there were a few headless rats in that order.
Switched to TMF and haven't looked back. They are always clean, whole and just incredibly well packed.

Is there a price difference in the 2? Do you ever get stuck together rats (I hate that)? Like the OP I'm sure, I would pay a little more for quality sorry to Jack the thread, I was going to ask the same question :p

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I997 using Tapatalk

[The Serpent Merchant]

I use rodent pro

[MidSouthMorphs]

I have used Rodent Pro for years. I have no complaints, but different customers have different experiences.

[maze031]

I like Layne Labs. Everytime I order from RP or MD it seems the rats are ragedy looking. Layne labs always has nice, clean, non-bloody, white rats. They don't smell, and they never stick together.

[Daybreaker]

Rodent Pro for me

[Salamander Rising]

Thinking about ordering some bulk F/T, with almost 10 snakes to feed its time to buy in bulk!

I would like to know whose tried either. What you liked, what you didn't like. Any bad experiences, and good? Pretty much all info is useful. If you have a different company to suggest, let me know!

Thanks everyone!

I bought mice from RodentPro at a show once and they looked as if they'd died of starvation and they caused loose stools in my snakes.

The ones I just got from MiceDirect were the ones pictured on my "Scary Mice!" thread.

They had scabs, bald spots, weird puncture wounds and were generally poor quality.

I'll never buy from either company again.

I'm going back to the last show we attended to get more of the great quality feeders that sadly, I didn't buy enough of that day.

[I have no idea who they were, sorry]

I've heard good things about Layne Labs, though.

[purplemuffin]

I have bought from rodentpro, mice direct, and now the big cheese rodents factory (they are right down the street from me! No shipping!)

For me, big cheese was the best--the rats you get are um, "processed" specifically FOR your order, they don't have a stockpile of frozen rodents where they just grab the size. This means you can even ask for specific orders. I've heard of people with particularly picky snakes who wanted to have gender specific orders and such and they were able to do that for them. They were the freshest rats I had ever seen to be honest, probably because they had only been frozen that morning. Nice clean packaging as well.

I did have a fine experience with both the other companies, but nothing as fresh as the big cheese rodent factory. Getting a call as the order is being first put in the freezer is great and I guess it just made me feel like I was getting better 'meat' for my snakes. Plus I guess since I don't have to pay shipping, that's quite nice as a bonus as well! So I stick with them.

My biggest problems with rodent pro/mice direct---Rodent pro gave me weird sizes in my order. The rat hoppers were sometimes a little bigger or smaller, some were a lot bigger or smaller. It wasn't too big of a deal, but if I had a smaller snake that wasn't still growing, a lot of the larger ones would have ended up being wasted. As far as mice direct, the rodents were fine--maybe a little 'stale' looking compared to what I saw now at big cheese, but certainly hadn't 'gone bad'.. The packaging was funky though.. They were all just sort of tossed into the bag in a big..messy..knot. It would take a good few minutes to pull just one out while undoing the tangled feet and ears and..oh goodness that one's ear just came off because it was frozen to the other one and It was kind of gross at times. Just having to pull them apart and worry if an arm was going to come off it was so tightly attached to the pile. Thankfully our snakes were eating quite a lot of them at the time(we needed a larger size to be honest, so they were eating multiples), so it was okay if you couldn't separate just one and had to pull out 3-4 that were tied together.

[Clementine_3]

Is there a price difference in the 2? Do you ever get stuck together rats (I hate that)?

I have not compared prices in a long time but bet they are more
No, they are not stuck together at all. The rats (small and larger) are placed on styrofoam meat trays, all lined up and neat/organized. Mice are just in a lump yet not really stuck together too badly, they separate very easily.