#1 both of those pewters are good looking animals I would keep the one that feeds the best, as it will be breeding size faster, if they are both eating extremely well I would possibly keep both If I had to decide to keep only one and they were both eating good I would prefer #1
#2 Those of you saying trade in on a pied that was not the question asked. I personally have 0 pieds and plan on buying 0 more they are something that is well overrated double recessive mutations are the only thing cool about pieds albino pied or dreamcicle not many jaw dropping co-dom pied crosses out there.
#3 I know my dislike of the pied's is going to stir the stew but if you all wanna talk about pieds go to a thread about pieds and dont take the thunder away from these peoples awesome Pewters