Hi shellie, it's hard to tell from those pics, but neither eye looks as bad as that picture you included in your first post. I'm going to second the suggestion that you bump his humidity next shed--maybe put him in a tub if he's normally in a tank?-- and also repeat the suggestion to stop messing with his eye and take him to a good herp vet.

I've had a couple of scares with my black pastel male because he's had dimpled, crusty-looking eyes after a shed. I rubbed at them for a while---but there was no extra eyecap, he just had a dimple from the low humidity and rubbing his head.

It's happened twice, and it's scary, because I could have blinded him if I'd kept it up. Now I put him the tubs whenever I see he's in shed.

Get your Nergal to a vet. And don't poke at his eyes in the meantime!