Do Girls want a huge engagement ring...

[LizardPants]

if you are MORE than capable of getting a good sized ring and you get them the cheapest one available, it might say that you are moderately to very cheap.

That's an insightful post, but here's another perspective. It shows that you're smart, you can manage your finances, you know the truth about the diamond trade, and you're not susceptible: to a sales pitch, marketing ploy, or the shallow desires of a spoiled little girl.