Xbox 360 for sure. Online play is the best (and more challenging) Plus i like xbox more.... idk. Never had the red rings yet, i have had my xbox for a bit over a year now, only problems ive had is that sometimes it goes retarded and wont read a disc, or says that the disc is dirty when the disc is spotless. Sometimes when i put a game in it trys to play a DVD so i have to re do it...

Paying for live stinks but its not that big of a deal if you buy a 12 month deal... its only like $40, or you can get a package...