This is a good point and I would have to consider how often do Herpstats fail (If I use the Herpstat II which would control the front and back separately). Otherwise I would be using two separate thermostats and would have to consider the odds of two failing at the same time. I will have a unit that can control multiple temperatures or multiple units to control the different temperatures.
Considering the worst happens and both thermostats go out and I am using 24" deep tubs. It would leave 12-16" of space in the middle depending on spacing and whether 3 or 4" flexwatt was used. This is a good argument against 11" or 17".