not always!
i seriously though i would do a nice colorfull sunfish.
a crappie might get too large around 14 inches
a perch would be cool but they get like 14 inches sometimes larger
alot of native fish get too large, but those are pretty much the most interesting fish i would keep in a tank that small.
now if you were talking 55 -75 gallon i would do a walleye.
also note that it must be of legal size limit to have it, so i would go catch a 10" largemouth bass. also bass can get like 18-20" and well into 15lbs or so