I'm certainly not an expert, so I'll just go on my gut instinct... and I am digging #2 the most. I just love the rich buttery colors - in fact, he/she almost looks like a butter morph! All three are gorgeous, but #1 is too light for my taste and #3 is too dark, whereas the middle one is just right. Very nice lessers regardless, and I'd happily take any of them off your hands.