Two different breeders? If so...two different cameras, two different lighting situations...it's really, really hard to judge true color based on internet pictures, unless the two animals were side-by-side in the same photo.

Personally, I'd snap up the reduced pattern one in a heartbeat. Not only is her pattern really pretty, but her blushing is insane as well. She's gorgeous. #2 is nice and the colors SEEM very pretty...but she still looks more "common" to me. Just my personal opinion, of course.