Logo Help

[Samuel]

I have a guy working on a logo for me. He sent me some ideas and sample this morning .. and I want thoughts.

The Battlement will be a section of the website and also a monthly newsletter ... I will leave it at that for now.

[likebull1]

The first one is kinda an eye sore, the second one is OK but i really like the 3rd one

[Freakie_frog]

Love the third one.

[abuja]

The third one definitely.

[Ladydragon]

I like the third one as well.

[Samuel]

It's kind of interestin to hear the repsonses ... on this site (the reptile site), everyone so far has loved the 3rd one.. the one out of the 3 to have a reptile in it. I posted these on another site that is mostly young males into video games and the reaction thus far is for 1 and 2, maybe a combination of both.

Interesting.

Keep the thoughts going .. it's helping me decide.

[Jyson]

I like them all, but I would say the third would make the best logo.

[stinker2009]

I wouldn't go with the first. Like it was already said, major eye sore. Too much going on and it pops out, not in a good way. 2 is much cleaner but like the rest, I like 3

[Samuel]

An idea that was floated was to place the axe from 1 in the 3's hand.

[Freakie_frog]

On I think the spear is simple and wont destract from the name of the logo.