Quote Originally Posted by Morphie View Post
Does she have to give me the egg? No. Should she? Yes, because even if it's a boring male normal, it would mean infinitely more to me to hatch and keep him than it would for her. She chooses not to, and that's fine, but it's really lame of her considering the kindness I offered when she needed it.

Yes, it's emotional, and that is what this thread is about. The business end of everything is fine, but don't let your emotions get involved with this girl, because she will not reciprocate or take care of yours, should you be the one in need.
I don't agree that she "should" give you the egg either though. Again, your opinion is driven by emotion. You posted this as a warning to other sellers. A warning not to get emotionally invested in Kristy? A business transaction should have nothing to do with hurt feelings. You were under no obligation to give her breaks, and if those breaks came with conditions, you should have made those conditions clear at the time of making the deal.

Would it be a nice thing to do? Sure. But she doesn't have to, nor "should" she.