Caramel Pastel Mystery

[BChambers]

I say: Prove it out! If it is really just a caramel and you breed it to a normal, then you shouldnt get a pastel. Right?

That's the problem-I DID breed it to a normal (het caramel), and I DID get a pastel! The second clutch he sired just now pipped-2 eggs, both normal caramel hets. Not enough eggs to begin to prove anything though...