Wow, I've definitely learned a lot from reading through this thread. My BP will take either Live or F/T and she's big enough now to where a mid-sized mouse is perfect for her. I just got a breeding group of rats and I'm really torn on what method to use when they actually begin breeding. I know I only have one BP right now and it might not seem to make sense to some people for me to have rats to breed for feeders but they are my pets also. I'm thinking though that with some rats having 10-15 babies in a litter I'll wind up having to euthanize and freeze some of them for a later feeding even if I do have 2-3 BPs by then. I could not see myself "whacking" one of my rats. That's just not right.
Hey Glory, could you possibly PM me or post how you made and use this CO2 chamber? I've seen some other versions but they all seem to require dry ice and no place up here seems to carry that unless you want to buy it in bulk from a chemical supply co.
As for the OP I would never try to kill a mouse the way that you did but you didn't know any better at the time, now you do. So hopefully you will never feel the need to put an animal through suffering like that again.