I like the first ones pattern BUT she is kind of small for a 12 don't you guys think? Number 2 is an okay weight for the year (not the greatest) and has a nice pattern and price. Number 3 seems like the best option IF you want to make ghosts which you said you did not. I would go with 3 to keep ghost in my back pocket for later but if you are dead set on no ghost 2 is best option.