I do not, in my own life, trust karma to take of me, and I do not trust it to take care of Stina.
What was done by Casey is wrong. I believe she is currently compounding the disgusting action she took by planning to steal a litter.
Words are powerful. Community is powerful. If many of us talk loud enough, long enough, perhaps others will listen and Casey will not be able to sell the stolen litter or, anything else.
At this point, considering her silence and absence of effort to make this right, I think her rep is totally trashed, and she did that to herself.