Also, after reading my details, I jumped around and confused a few of you. 3.5 years I went to the vet. After about 4 months of owning him I thought something was wrong with him because he LIVED in his water dish. To the extent I had to put a bigger dish in there so he could actually fit his body in it, otherwise he would just flood his cage jamming himself into his smaller dish. That was when I went to the vet to see if something was wrong with him and she told me I just had a weird one.
Fast forward to last week he was showing symptoms of this problem. His urine started smelling just before Christmas however the thing that made me think something was wrong was when he passed some of the goo the vet ended up plush out of him. I had taken him off his breeding rotation at the beginning of Dec because he has missed 3 consecutive meals (just my policy with my males). The first sign he showed me was just before Christmas, but from what the vet told me even if I had brought him in then it wouldnt have changed the outcome.