» Site Navigation
0 members and 716 guests
No Members online
Most users ever online was 47,180, 07-16-2025 at 05:30 PM.
» Today's Birthdays
» Stats
Members: 75,905
Threads: 249,107
Posts: 2,572,121
Top Poster: JLC (31,651)
|
-
BP's and Children..help
We currently have 5 Ball Pythons and 2 crested geckos which we were planning on getting into breeding BP's until this past Wednesday. I have 3 children ages 7, 3, and 2. On Wednesday my 3 year old son had to be rushed to the ER due to a fever of 104.1 (that we couldn't brake), vomiting, diarrhea, rapid resting heart rate and extremely lethargic. Turns out he had gotten salmonella, not only in his stomach but also found out it had gotten into his bloodstream. This is his 2nd day of antibiotics and he is finally returning to normalish, saying he isn't sick anymore. Needless to say we are very relieved that it seems he is getting over this. Now i have kept various reptiles for over 20 years and never gotten sick because of them. Also myself, wife and all kids wash there hands after handling any of our reptiles. The doctors were saying either he got salmonella from something he ate (under cooked) or the reptiles. We all eat the same stuff so i think its a little odd that no one else had gotten it. The doctors are saying we need to get rid of all reptiles until all of the kids are at least 5 years old. Of course, they are all currently up for re homing and will most likely be gone in a day or 2 because i am not willing to take a risk like that again. My question is, has anyone else had any experience like this? or been told no reptiles in the home with children? Lastly, is there any type of reptile that would be safest to keep?
-
I'm so sorry you and your son went through this!!!
I would honestly not rehome the reptiles though. There are risks with any pet, going outside to play, going to school or the supermarket. Unless your child is found to have some severely compromised immune system (leukemia, organ transplant recipient, congenital immune suppression), this is not necessary.
If you practice good hand-washing and don't allow the children to hold the reptiles for now, you should be okay. As you can see in my sig, we have lots of pets and some of them do carry risks. We just wash our hands and keep things reasonably clean.
Also talk to the vet about possibly treating the animals in question. I have no idea if this is something they do or not, but it would be a good conversation to have.
P.S. While I cannot and will not give official medical advice, even as a registered nurse with 4 years Pediatric ICU experience, I can give you advice as a fellow parent and tell you what I would do in your situation.
-
Re: BP's and Children..help
Quote:
Originally Posted by smoothdog89
We currently have 5 Ball Pythons and 2 crested geckos which we were planning on getting into breeding BP's until this past Wednesday. I have 3 children ages 7, 3, and 2. On Wednesday my 3 year old son had to be rushed to the ER due to a fever of 104.1 (that we couldn't brake), vomiting, diarrhea, rapid resting heart rate and extremely lethargic. Turns out he had gotten salmonella, not only in his stomach but also found out it had gotten into his bloodstream. This is his 2nd day of antibiotics and he is finally returning to normalish, saying he isn't sick anymore. Needless to say we are very relieved that it seems he is getting over this. Now i have kept various reptiles for over 20 years and never gotten sick because of them. Also myself, wife and all kids wash there hands after handling any of our reptiles. The doctors were saying either he got salmonella from something he ate (under cooked) or the reptiles. We all eat the same stuff so i think its a little odd that no one else had gotten it. The doctors are saying we need to get rid of all reptiles until all of the kids are at least 5 years old. Of course, they are all currently up for re homing and will most likely be gone in a day or 2 because i am not willing to take a risk like that again. My question is, has anyone else had any experience like this? or been told no reptiles in the home with children? Lastly, is there any type of reptile that would be safest to keep?
I’ll be straight forward with you, I have a toddler too around that age and he is an absolute handful. There’s a big possibility he could of gone into the trash and touched something infected with salmonella. Toddlers move so much and get into anything they can. Unless you recently let your child hold one of your reptiles or you have them easily accessible to where they can handle them without you guys knowing, there’s no way to know where he got sick from. I personally would not want to rehome all my reptiles with out more certainty that they are the actual cause.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Re: BP's and Children..help
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewmanLovesSnakes
I’ll be straight forward with you, I have a toddler too around that age and he is an absolute handful. There’s a big possibility he could of gone into the trash and touched something infected with salmonella. Toddlers move so much and get into anything they can. Unless you recently let your child hold one of your reptiles or you have them easily accessible to where they can handle them without you guys knowing, there’s no way to know where he got sick from. I personally would not want to rehome all my reptiles with out more certainty that they are the actual cause.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I hope your child makes a full recovery! You can have the reps test for salmonella by your Vet. I have only found salmonella in wild caught reps. Now, the pig ears from china are another story.
Good luck!
-
Most medical doctors know very little about reptiles & are quick to paint them all with the same brush, ie. saying they carry salmonella. In truth, it's far more likely found in aquatic turtles, and WAY more likely your child got sick by accidentally coming into contact with a cutting board or towel that contacted raw chicken in your kitchen than anything to do with your snakes or lizards. And don't forget the grocery store! Do you use the sanitizing wipes on the carts??? People put raw meat in the carts and the packages may have leaks & germs on the outside, hint hint! Your doctor just jumped to an unfounded conclusion, IMO.
You have my very best wishes for your son's speedy recovery...while I understand your priorities, I'd not be so quick to get rid of your reptiles over this. Little kids
stick their hands everywhere, as was already suggested, plus they are smaller & have less resistance to these things compared to older kids or adults. I understand your panic...no one wants their children to be seriously ill...it's scary...but IMO it's NOT the snakes that are an issue (& I have 34 years of keeping a house FULL of snakes & some lizards, along with raising my own rodents & having multiple dogs), & as a parent of small children, getting rid of your reptiles is not any sort of guarantee that your children will never get such an illness again.
-
My young nephews (3 and 4) have handled and petted my reptiles many times before without issues. They wash their hands afterward. They get sick mainly from other kids or just because. Like the other posts, most likely your child caught it somewhere else. Most likely your doctor is wrong, just as they diagnose my niece that she is allergic to cats and cannot have them, but yet she is fine when she is playing with the neighbor's cats. Fear can overshadow reason.
However, if I were you, I may probably do the same. We don't have kids but my fur pets, especially my cat Happy who is my heart cat, when she was mysteriously hurt, the first thought in my mind was to rehome my other cats who may have (But most likely not) injured her. I wanted to protect her and shield her from every potential harm. That parental instinct, I think, if you need to rehome your pets, I would not judge you for.
-
There's always a risk. That's like saying you can't have cats because the risk of toxoplasmosis. Obviously, you should do what you want to do, but if you don't let them handle the snakes and you're washing your hands, I wouldn't think it necessary to rehome.
I have a dubia roach colony of about 10k, and I've heard you can get allergies from them, but so far so good.
I had my first ball python at 7, and I handled him a lot, and I was totally fine.
-
Speaking of doctors being prejudiced about snakes & other reptiles, just consider how many veterinarians do not like or are afraid of them & will NOT treat them
under any circumstances...and vets are well-educated ANIMAL lovers, right? :D Sadly, many physicians that we see know zip about herps & are happy to share
the same misinformation that's been around for years. Not saying there is "zero" risk, but you cannot raise your children in a bubble to prevent all risks no matter
what, & statistics favor all the other culprits as the source of salmonella (contamination found in the home kitchen or grocery stores, other kids, under-cooked food,
etc.). I wonder what the vet would charge to test your pets for salmonella?
-
Re: BP's and Children..help
If salmonella is the big concern here then I hope you don't have any cats or dogs. Their feces can also transmit salmonella. Not implying your kids play with poop lol but I too have small children and they will sometimes "help" clean the litter box or pick up dog poo in the yard. We're cautious and we've never had an issue but that's not to say there isn't risk. My point is the reptiles themselves aren't solely to blame. Whether they're the culprits or not many diseases- salmonella included -can be transmitted by all animals not just reptiles.
-
Re: BP's and Children..help
Quote:
Originally Posted by Toad37
If salmonella is the big concern here then I hope you don't have any cats or dogs. Their feces can also transmit salmonella. Not implying your kids play with poop lol but I too have small children and they will sometimes "help" clean the litter box or pick up dog poo in the yard. We're cautious and we've never had an issue but that's not to say there isn't risk. My point is the reptiles themselves aren't solely to blame. Whether they're the culprits or not many diseases- salmonella included -can be transmitted by all animals not just reptiles.
Yep our vet said the same thing when I enquired about my snakes and salmonella... he said our dog was a greater risk !
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
-
So if it's transmitted by dog or cat feces, look at how many yards & parks have contaminated lawns? ;) (hint: probably over 90%, just guessing)
Even when the stuff is picked up, some is left behind that kids could touch accidentally, on shoes, etc.
-
Although my specialty is not pediatrics, I am a physician (licensed MD), so I can perhaps provide some additional information, though I will emphasize that I am not giving any specific recommendations here as a medical provider; this is only for potential educational insights.
I reviewed some of the current medical literature specifically regarding reptile-associated salmonellosis (RAS), and these points may be relevant for our consideration:
- The most common manifestation of RAS is gastrointestinal disease - diarrhea, abdominal discomfort, fever, possible nausea/vomiting. This is consistent with the most common presentation of Salmonella infections as a whole. However, there is also the possibility of invasive RAS, which is much less common but also more serious, and can include bacteremia (spread into the bloodstream), meningitis, or bone/joint infections.
- While it is true that most of the RAS exposures are linked to turtles, there have also been cases documented related to lizards and snakes that are common in the pet trade.
- Invasive RAS is more commonly seen in children of younger age (especially infants under 6 months, but can happen in the toddler age range too), and, notably, is more likely to be seen associated with reptile exposures that are not turtles.
- A factor to be taken into account that probably contributes to this is that these snakes and lizards are usually pets that are kept indoors, i.e. the setting that infants and very young children are also "confined" to for the majority of the time. Contrast this with turtles that may often be kept outside, and the older age at which children begin to engage with more outdoor play.
- With all that said, if a child is generally healthy and not chronically immunocompromised, I cannot recall seeing any medical practice guidelines that say physicians should recommend that people completely get rid of their reptilian pets. Instead, preventive recommendations emphasize hand hygiene practices in the household.
- Since the Salmonella bacteria is shed through the reptile's feces, let's return to the realm of reptile-keeping practices -- keeping the reptiles' enclosures clean is very important to minimize Salmonella exposure risk, as well as having a strict hand-washing protocol in place for every family member, not just the children, after any reptile handling. These are the measures that will greatly reduce the risk of RAS.
- If you completely remove pet reptiles from the home, then yes, that will of course reduce your risk of reptile-associated Salmonella to zero (assuming you also have zero interactions with reptiles at pet stores, at a friend's house, etc.). However, it will not change your risk of exposure to Salmonella from the other, more common sources that many here have already mentioned.
With all of this in mind, I do find it completely understandable if OP chooses to not keep reptiles, at least for the time being while the kids are still young. However, as others have experienced, it is also quite feasible for pet reptiles and young children to safely coexist. Both are reasonable, and neither would be considered a poor parenting choice, in my personal opinion.
-
I was sure hoping you'd share your thoughts on this, RedRabbit. :gj: You've definitely shared some great information, & invasive RAS is pretty scary, I admit.
And all this time I've only heard of the OTHER "RAS". :D ("reptile acquisition syndrome")
-
I realized I got so caught up in presenting the information bullet points, I neglected to address OP individually. OP, I am very sorry to hear about what happened with your 3-year-old son, and I am glad to hear that he is recovering fairly quickly. It sounds like you and your family are already very attentive to hand-washing after handling the pet reptiles, so I applaud you for that, and that does slightly lower my concern for it actually being RAS in your case. With that said, as I mentioned above, I absolutely would not fault you if you are choosing not to have reptiles in the home right now. Unfortunately, I cannot think of any specific reptile or amphibian species that do not come with at least some possibility of carrying Salmonella.
You may already be doing these as well, but if you do decide to keep your reptiles, here are other general practices that can help minimize risk:
- Hand-washing should be with hot water and plenty of soap, should cover the entire hands including under the nails, and should involve scrubbing for a duration of at least 20 seconds. The CDC has a helpful page on effective hand-washing, here: https://www.cdc.gov/handwashing/when...ndwashing.html
If your reptiles venture onto your wrists/forearms while handling them, then include these areas of your arms when washing as well.
- The same hand-washing rules apply when touching any reptile equipment/toys or anything in their enclosures, even if no contact is made with the animal itself.
- The reptiles' food/water dishes and other equipment should be washed in a separate sink from what the family commonly uses in the kitchen or bathroom. As a general rule, reptiles and reptile "stuff" should be kept out of the kitchen/dining area entirely.
- No eating or drinking while around the reptiles. If you have a designated reptile room, enforce a "no (human) food or drink" rule for that room in particular.
- If the reptiles are sometimes brought out of the reptile room/area for play in other parts of the house, lay down a specified surface for them to play on, such as a blanket or a tablecloth - something that can be washed regularly and thoroughly. Do not let them free-roam across common household surfaces.
-
Re: BP's and Children..help
I have 4 kids, all grown up now, but as a parent I understand that if a child is in the hospital and the dr. recommends that you do something, you are probably going to do it. That being said, if you rehome the animals or not, that’s your decision, I am just a little upset that the Dr. would suggest that you do that and not suggest testing the animals first. I really hope everything comes out ok.
-
Re: BP's and Children..help
First, I am terribly sorry your son got sick.
Secondly, I am not a child, nor do I have children, but I am heavily immune suppressed being a kidney transplant recipient. I also have my nieces and nephews over frequently and they handle many of my 13 reptiles (both lizards and snakes).
When I was first getting transplanted, I was told to get rid of all my reptiles because of salmonella risk. I freaked out and re-homed my two snakes, but kept my Beardie because my wife at the time (now ex) said she would care for him. Guess, what, she didn't, at all. I ended up feeding him, cleaning for him, and handling him. The same for all my other reptiles from then (2012) until today. Guess what else? I have never gotten sick from them. I clean their tanks, feed, handle, etc.
Having said that, I am incredibly careful. I use hand sanitizer and/or wash between animals and always do a thorough hand and arm wash when done. I do my best not to touch feces but if I do wash immediately and thoroughly. I also keep my hands away from my mouth and nose, consciously.
I agree, if your son got sick from the reptiles, it was because of access to feces and/or touching an animal that had feces on them, or touched near the vent, and then likely touched his face. Or, as others have said, he contracted it another way.
When my nieces and nephews, or anyone, come over, I preach cleanliness. I especially do with the reptiles, to the point that they ask me if I washed my hands between reptiles, like clockwork.
I made the mistake of getting rid of two animals I loved because of what the doctors said, not understanding they do not completely understand the risk and fear what they don't know.
It's a personal decision, but my guess is make cleanliness fun and make clear boundaries if you think it was the reptiles.
I also know breeders who have had transplants and care for 300 snakes at a time or more.
Wishing your son a speedy recovery and all the best with your decision.
-
Re: BP's and Children..help
Quote:
Originally Posted by FollowTheSun
I'm so sorry you and your son went through this!!!
I would honestly not rehome the reptiles though. There are risks with any pet, going outside to play, going to school or the supermarket. Unless your child is found to have some severely compromised immune system (leukemia, organ transplant recipient, congenital immune suppression), this is not necessary.
If you practice good hand-washing and don't allow the children to hold the reptiles for now, you should be okay. As you can see in my sig, we have lots of pets and some of them do carry risks. We just wash our hands and keep things reasonably clean.
Also talk to the vet about possibly treating the animals in question. I have no idea if this is something they do or not, but it would be a good conversation to have.
P.S. While I cannot and will not give official medical advice, even as a registered nurse with 4 years Pediatric ICU experience, I can give you advice as a fellow parent and tell you what I would do in your situation.
Well i certainly don't want to re-home them, as i have been researching you can even get salmonella from dogs and cats(which i didn't know, nor do we have any). Thank you for the response, i wanted to get more advice before just selling all of our pets. I think if the kids just don't handle them, except for my 7 year old, they should be just fine.
-
Re: BP's and Children..help
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewmanLovesSnakes
I’ll be straight forward with you, I have a toddler too around that age and he is an absolute handful. There’s a big possibility he could of gone into the trash and touched something infected with salmonella. Toddlers move so much and get into anything they can. Unless you recently let your child hold one of your reptiles or you have them easily accessible to where they can handle them without you guys knowing, there’s no way to know where he got sick from. I personally would not want to rehome all my reptiles with out more certainty that they are the actual cause.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Thank you!! They are definitely a hand full and i thought the ER doctor jumped to conclusions very quickly. All Of the Reptiles have the Exo Terra Tanks (on Purpose) because the kids arent able to unlock the door plus they are out of reach, so the only way they are able to hold any is if theyre being supervised. I agree he could have gotten it from literally anywhere, and we have some BP's we've had for a while and paid a pretty good amount for. thank you for the response.
-
Re: BP's and Children..help
Quote:
Originally Posted by 303_enfield
I hope your child makes a full recovery! You can have the reps test for salmonella by your Vet. I have only found salmonella in wild caught reps. Now, the pig ears from china are another story.
Good luck!
Thank you! he is not fully recovered yet but this is his 3rd day with antibiotics and he's doing so much better. I was unaware the vets could do that, i will have to ask them about it. thanks again!
-
Re: BP's and Children..help
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bogertophis
Most medical doctors know very little about reptiles & are quick to paint them all with the same brush, ie. saying they carry salmonella. In truth, it's far more likely found in aquatic turtles, and WAY more likely your child got sick by accidentally coming into contact with a cutting board or towel that contacted raw chicken in your kitchen than anything to do with your snakes or lizards. And don't forget the grocery store! Do you use the sanitizing wipes on the carts??? People put raw meat in the carts and the packages may have leaks & germs on the outside, hint hint! Your doctor just jumped to an unfounded conclusion, IMO.
You have my very best wishes for your son's speedy recovery...while I understand your priorities, I'd not be so quick to get rid of your reptiles over this. Little kids
stick their hands everywhere, as was already suggested, plus they are smaller & have less resistance to these things compared to older kids or adults. I understand your panic...no one wants their children to be seriously ill...it's scary...but IMO it's NOT the snakes that are an issue (& I have 34 years of keeping a house FULL of snakes & some lizards, along with raising my own rodents & having multiple dogs), & as a parent of small children, getting rid of your reptiles is not any sort of guarantee that your children will never get such an illness again.
It funny you mention the shopping cart wipes because my wife is so anal about wiping down the entire cart prior to putting any of the in them haha I had my suspicions regarding the doctors advice and i thank all you for the responses. As i was thinking its almost impossible to pinpoint how he had gotten it, plus the fact that no one else got it. Thanks again and i think we will be keeping the reptiles and maybe our younger kids wont be allowed to handle them until they're 5.
-
Re: BP's and Children..help
Quote:
Originally Posted by smoothdog89
It funny you mention the shopping cart wipes because my wife is so anal about wiping down the entire cart prior to putting any of the in them haha I had my suspicions regarding the doctors advice and i thank all you for the responses. As i was thinking its almost impossible to pinpoint how he had gotten it, plus the fact that no one else got it. Thanks again and i think we will be keeping the reptiles and maybe our younger kids wont be allowed to handle them until they're 5.
I think that's a good plan. :gj: Also checking with your vet about testing your snakes? (And tell your wife she's doing the right thing on the carts, lol.)
May you all stay very healthy from now on. :sunny:
|