Should I get a fish

I want one :D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D

You joined BP.net to ask about fish?

I have an outdoor Koi pond. All I can say is it's a good amount of work. Especially when they leaves start falling. I threaten to get rid of it and turn it into a crocodile habitat often.


As for your poll I feel I need more information before I suggest a pet to a person.

Indoors or outdoors, successfully keeping fish -even just one fish- should not be decided on a whim. Good care & success takes some investment of education time, money, & a sense of responsibility (ie. a firm commitment to regular care). All pets deserve no less from their owners- they're living creatures- so whether you're ready for one, it's impossible to say. ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bogertophis

Indoors or outdoors, successfully keeping fish -even just one fish- should not be decided on a whim. Good care & success takes some investment of education time, money, & a sense of responsibility (ie. a firm commitment to regular care). All pets deserve no less from their owners- they're living creatures- so whether you're ready for one, it's impossible to say. ;)

---

This^^

Keeping a fish is no different than keeping any other animal. They deserve the same level of care and respect as say a snake, a dog, or a cat. None of these animals do you go into without a lot of thought. People tend to look at a fish tank as something easy to do, and it is, with experience. The initial set up phase is incredibly important, cycling your new tank is probably the most overlooked and incorrectly done part of fish keeping. You also have to look at your budget. People think fishkeeping is cheap, but it can get expensive quickly depending on what kind of set up you're interesting in running.

Lastly, fish are not a set and forget pet. You're talking water changes, substrate vacuuming, feeding, live plant care if you go that route, filter maintenance, so on and so forth. This is a lot to think about other than "I want one."

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hugsplox

This^^

Keeping a fish is no different than keeping any other animal. They deserve the same level of care and respect as say a snake, a dog, or a cat. None of these animals do you go into without a lot of thought. People tend to look at a fish tank as something easy to do, and it is, with experience. The initial set up phase is incredibly important, cycling your new tank is probably the most overlooked and incorrectly done part of fish keeping. You also have to look at your budget. People think fishkeeping is cheap, but it can get expensive quickly depending on what kind of set up you're interesting in running.

Lastly, fish are not a set and forget pet. You're talking water changes, substrate vacuuming, feeding, live plant care if you go that route, filter maintenance, so on and so forth. This is a lot to think about other than "I want one."

---

THIS too ^ ^ ^. Most creatures are fun to "have" for a little while, but then what? Make sure you choose pets that you'll enjoy LIVING with for as long as they live. Do your "homework" about them first- otherwise you're likely to have regrets. And always be sure your "budget" can handle routine care as well as emergency medical help.

Then on top of care some fish are long lived....longer than snakes. Plenty of parents find this out the hard way when they get 10 year old lil Johnny a snake and the thing is still kicking when it is time to move off to college and it becomes theirs. Or like buying a parrot of tortoise some fish can be a life long investment.....like Koi.

Then like mentioned about the start up on a full real deal setup is not cheap. I looked into it and really wanted a salt water tank. After I did my homework I decided it was not what I needed at the time. My Koi pond gives me more than enough to do. One thing I really enjoy about my pond is it is large and on a hot day after some yard work I get in. Relax with a cigar and some whiskey. My wife on the other hand will not get in. :rolleyes: Even though the water is clear and we know exactly what is in it. I grew up in the country though so swimming in creeks and ponds was a norm. Saw one of my first Coral Snakes swimming at a beaver dam.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KMG

Then on top of care some fish are long lived....longer than snakes. Plenty of parents find this out the hard way when they get 10 year old lil Johnny a snake and the thing is still kicking when it is time to move off to college and it becomes theirs. Or like buying a parrot of tortoise some fish can be a life long investment.....like Koi.

---

Exactly, plus depending on what species of fish you get, you may not be able to have just one. I keep South American tetras, most of which are schooling fish, so I can't just have one, I have to buy 6, 8, 10 depending on the type of fish.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hugsplox

Exactly, plus depending on what species of fish you get, you may not be able to have just one. I keep South American tetras, most of which are schooling fish, so I can't just have one, I have to buy 6, 8, 10 depending on the type of fish.

---

While others you can only have one.

Or some that will need a larger tank a few times in their life. Bigger tank....bigger pump....bigger heater....bigger filter.....bigger budget needed.

That's as vague as saying you want a reptile. Lol. What are you thinking of keeping? What is your max tank size? What are your constraints (time/money/space...).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KMG

Then on top of care some fish are long lived....longer than snakes. Plenty of parents find this out the hard way when they get 10 year old lil Johnny a snake and the thing is still kicking when it is time to move off to college and it becomes theirs. Or like buying a parrot of tortoise some fish can be a life long investment.....like Koi.

---

I was surprised to learn clowns and tangs can live 20-30 years.

Yall ever watch this guy? Fish have taken over everything....even his swimming pool. I guess his pool and my pond are really about the same thing. I wish mine was indoors like his.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fLk6IlPSh2k

His "pool."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UGKnV50T3kc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KMG

Yall ever watch this guy? Fish have taken over everything....even his swimming pool. I guess his pool and my pond are really about the same thing. I wish mine was indoors like his.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fLk6IlPSh2k

---

Very interesting- I like his idea of using tile on the bottom for ease of cleaning (though appearance takes getting used to), & that sand waterfall is amazing! This guy really loves his fish! :gj:

When your husband or wife says you spend too much on your reptiles direct them here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vhs6D0MExzI

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KMG

Yall ever watch this guy? Fish have taken over everything....even his swimming pool. I guess his pool and my pond are really about the same thing. I wish mine was indoors like his.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fLk6IlPSh2k

---

This guy is pretty cool. I saw this video a while back and I guess he takes in bigger fish that people purchase small not realizing how big they get. I'm sure there are other reasons why he takes them in, but it's neat that there's someone doing something.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KMG

When your husband or wife says you spend too much on your reptiles direct them here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vhs6D0MExzI

---

That's super cool. That guy is dedicated.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QeOQnCBX2Dw

FYI, to the OP: I voted "no" because the ONLY reason you gave for getting a fish was that you "want one"- nothing to convince me that you'll be a good pet owner for a fish, nor any other pet experience you've had- just nothing to go on. I care about every kind of pet there is- they deserve good care from us because we're holding them captive, so without more to go on, I voted "no".

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bogertophis

FYI, to the OP: I voted "no" because the ONLY reason you gave for getting a fish was that you "want one"- nothing to convince me that you'll be a good pet owner for a fish, nor any other pet experience you've had- just nothing to go on. I care about every kind of pet there is- they deserve good care from us because we're holding them captive, so without more to go on, I voted "no".

---

This thread has made me want fish too......with chips.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KMG

This thread has made me want fish too......with chips.

---

:colbert: Go to your room! ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bogertophis

:colbert: Go to your room! ;)

---

Is that where the fish and chips are?:rofl:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KMG

Is that where the fish and chips are?:rofl:

---

You tell me? :cool:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bogertophis

You tell me? :cool:

---

Nope. Just got home. No fish and chips. Just a bulldog and a pit bull on my bed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KMG

Nope. Just got home. No fish and chips. Just a bulldog and a pit bull on my bed.

---

In that case, curb your appetite! No hot dogs for dinner! :O

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bogertophis

In that case, curb your appetite! No hot dogs for dinner! :O

---

They're both spoiled. Wouldn't be any good to eat. I mean they're laying on a Tempur Pedic!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KMG

They're both spoiled. Wouldn't be any good to eat. I mean they're laying on a Tempur Pedic!

---

:gj: As all dogs should be.

Psst, while this isn't a very serious poll, we're way off-topic. :hijackd: Time to get back...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bogertophis

:gj: As all dogs should be.

Psst, while this isn't a very serious poll, we're way off-topic. :hijackd: Time to get back...

---

Ha! I'll get back on track when the OP comes back.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KMG

Ha! I'll get back on track when the OP comes back.

---

It has been a little too quiet...

Thanks for all the help!!!!:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D

Decided to buy my third turtle instead. As much as I love fish, turtles are just too cool to not get another one.

As for the off topic discussion, I love fish and chips :D:D:D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WeezerFan204

Thanks for all the help!!!!:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D

Decided to buy my third turtle instead. As much as I love fish, turtles are just too cool to not get another one.

As for the off topic discussion, I love fish and chips :D:D:D

---

Weezer!!!! You're back!!!!

What kind of turtle?




I love me some good fish and chips.

I got a Reeves' turtle, i love the lil guys. A friend of mine had one and he was very cute. I knew that i'd get a Reeves' turtle next, it was just a matter of time. :D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D