Re: Best Dwarf Boa imperator locality
The 48"x24"x12" PVC cage would be more appropriate and a bit easier to work with, in my opinion. Since a female Sonoran could (and quite possibly would) reach around 5' by their mid- to late-teens, a 36" enclosure would be too small. Try to give whatever new boa you get as much space as you can afford (space-wise) to stretch out their lungs and get some exercise. I think you'll find the long-term health benefits are worth it.
Establishing a thermal gradient is also easier in a 48"x24" than a 36"x24". The additional 5" of height over a tub isn't much extra climbing room, but it at least provides the boas a few extra inches of height to haul themselves up to perch on things. They won't have this extra climbing room on the warm side if you decide to go with an RHP, though. If you happen to have the space for an 18" high or even a 24" high enclosure, I'd highly recommend getting one of those instead. The extra height makes it easier to reach in and clean (for you) and provides more room to climb and build muscle tone (for the boa). Given a basking shelf, appropriate RHP, and a good IR thermometer, establishing a good thermal gradient in these taller enclosures isn't as hard as you'd think. Just food for thought. :)