Professional boat builder, we tried GE SCS 1200 silicone it is used for building aquariums and tried 3m 5200 as well it also failed and it is a structural adhesive. The 5200 didn't fail quickly but it did fail (I think it was 2 years). Have you ever seen plexy move in water? Try it it is unbelievable how much it cups. Have you had a spill yet?
I'd suggest the PVC bottom it works like wood and can be fasted with silicone and screws it is hard to make waterproof but leaks are off the side and slow.