Which Should I Keep??

I'm with the rest, #1. Color is very nice, great contrast, pattern is a little broken but not bad and sides have a good amount of white. I'm sure it's just my phone and prob the camera angle/flash but #1 almost looks like a desert spider in color and pattern :)

The brightness and blushing on the back of number one is just amazing. I go for number one as well.

#1, without a doubt.

Both of them are nice, but #1 has an overall cleaner look to him, so that is who I'd keep.